Before you answer this question, there are a few important considerations you should bear in mind. First and foremost, it’s essential to know whether you’d like to round-trip between the two NLEs or you want to complete your project while utilizing only the provided tools and assets of either platform. Undoubtedly, the second option will save you a lot more time and effort down the road, but it may be initially intimidating to decide which piece of software will fit your needs better. To put things into perspective and make this decision easier for you, US-based colorist and filmmaker Casey Faris shares his thoughts on the matter that should eventually help you to make the best choice for yourself.
If your timeline in Premiere Pro CC consists mainly of similar shots that are captured in the same lighting conditions with close color tones, odds are you’ll be able to pull this off seamlessly by applying a single primary grade all at once. In that case, just put and Adjustment layer on the top of your edit and make the color grading adjustments accordingly. Occasionally, you may need to tweak a few shots further here and there, but overall this workflow will still be a lot more time-efficient and effective than sending your footage back and forth between the two editing applications all the time.
On the other hand, if you have a more complicated sequence consisting of multiple shots with different types of lighting or you need to deal with more scenes at once, then you might consider the option to use Resolve as your primary NLE and do the entire editing and color grading there. The other major factor according to Faris is how detailed you’re going to get with your color grading. If you tend to make multiple subtle adjustments in different parts of each clip while using complex tracking, masks or keys, then again picking DaVinci Resolve should still make more sense for color grading.
All in all, considering the type of shots along with the intricacy and level of detail of your color grading workflow, these are two of the main factors you should take into account before you decide which of the two platforms will fit your needs better. As a rule, for simple grades on similar shots use Premiere Pro whereas for more complicated color grading tasks opt for Resolve.
Of course, there are always exceptions to that rule as every project is different. So, whether you agree with Faris or not, feel free to share your insight on the topic below even if you have an entirely different approach when it comes to picking the right NLE for editing and color grading.
[source: Casey Faris]
Claim your copy of DAVINCI RESOLVE - SIMPLIFIED COURSE with 50% off! Get Instant Access!